Simplywallst: A Detailed Look for Value-Focused Investors
Simplywallst is the domain and colloquial shorthand for Simply Wall Street, a stock research platform that converts fundamental financial data into a five-axis snowflake score. The simplywallst approach is built for speed: a new user can screen any of the 100,000+ covered securities in under three minutes without reading a single financial statement. The platform scores each stock on value, future performance, past performance, financial health, and dividends. This post examines what simplywallst actually measures, what the P/E ratio, ROE, and P/B data it displays mean in context, and where the framework needs supplementing before you act on it.
The core point: simplywallst gives you reliable first-pass orientation and unreliable final verdicts on intrinsic value. The distinction is everything.
Key Takeaways
- Simplywallst produces a snowflake score from binary pass/fail checks aggregated across five axes, each scored 0-6.
- The P/E ratio is central to the simplywallst value axis, but the comparison is relative to sector medians rather than absolute, which penalizes high-ROIC businesses trading at justified premiums.
- ROE (return on equity) appears prominently in simplywallst reports. ROIC (return on invested capital) does not, which matters because the two metrics diverge sharply for heavily indebted businesses.
- Price-to-book (P/B) is one of the value checks. BRK.B at a P/B near 1.5 passes the check accurately. Most asset-light technology businesses score poorly on P/B regardless of cash flow quality.
- Simplywallst does not calculate or display ROIC, Piotroski F-Score, or EV/EBITDA in its default view.
- The platform is most accurate for health and dividend checks, and least accurate for intrinsic value conclusions where the underlying DCF model is non-transparent.
What Simplywallst Covers
The simplywallst platform covers individual equities, REITs, and ETFs. For individual equities the full five-axis snowflake is available. For ETFs the platform produces a holdings-weighted aggregate score. REIT coverage is available but incomplete: the simplywallst snowflake applies standard equity checks to REITs without adjusting for the fact that REITs are required to distribute most taxable income, which suppresses retained earnings and elevates debt metrics in ways that look negative on standard health checks but are structurally expected for the asset class.
Coverage spans the NYSE, NASDAQ, London Stock Exchange, Tokyo Stock Exchange, ASX, Frankfurt Exchange, Toronto Stock Exchange, and dozens of others. For U.S. large-cap names, data completeness is high. For mid-caps on smaller international exchanges, data gaps are common.
How Simplywallst Builds the Snowflake
Each axis draws from a set of individual checks. Passes accumulate points on a 0-6 scale per axis.
Value checks include: stock price below the estimated intrinsic value (two-stage DCF), P/E below industry median, P/B below industry median, and price-to-earnings-growth (PEG) below a threshold. A stock like BRK.B with a P/B near 1.5 passes the P/B check easily. A stock like AAPL at P/E near 28.3 typically fails the sector-median P/E comparison even though ROIC at 45.1% justifies the premium.
Future checks use analyst consensus estimates for revenue and earnings growth over one to three years. A company where consensus forecasts 20%+ EPS growth over three years passes more checks than one where analysts forecast flat earnings.
Past checks look at historical EPS and revenue growth. A five-year EPS CAGR above the market median passes. Consistent profitability over multiple consecutive years contributes positively.
Health checks include net debt-to-equity below a threshold, interest coverage above 3x earnings before interest, short-term assets exceeding short-term liabilities, and adequate cash runway. Investment-grade businesses typically score 4-6/6. Highly indebted businesses typically score 0-2/6.
Dividend checks cover yield level, dividend payment for at least five consecutive years, and payout ratio below a sustainability ceiling. Coca-Cola (KO) at a 3.0% yield with 62 consecutive years of dividend increases scores 6/6. A business that initiated a dividend two years ago scores much lower even if the payout is well-covered by cash flow.
The P/E Ratio in Simplywallst: What It Measures and Where It Fails
The P/E ratio is the most visible valuation metric in the simplywallst value checks. The platform compares each stock's trailing P/E to its sector median and flags stocks trading below the median as passing the check.
This creates a structural problem. A business with a P/E of 25 in a sector where the median is 30 passes. A business with a P/E of 22 in a sector where the median is 18 fails. The check captures relative cheapness within a sector, not absolute value.
The deeper issue is that P/E-versus-sector-median completely ignores capital efficiency. Apple (AAPL) at a P/E near 28.3 generates $45 of return for every $100 deployed in its business. A sector peer with a P/E of 20 and a ROIC of 8% is not a better investment just because its P/E is lower. The sector-median check treats them as equivalents.
For an explanation of how trailing and forward P/E should be interpreted alongside earnings quality adjustments, see the ValueMarkers glossary entry on P/E ratio, which covers normalized earnings, sector-specific norms, and the conditions under which P/E is and is not the right first multiple to use.
The ROE Display and Its Limits
Simplywallst displays ROE prominently in individual stock reports. ROE is return on equity, calculated as net income divided by shareholders' equity.
ROE is a useful but incomplete quality metric. The problem is that debt mechanically inflates ROE. A company earning $10 million on $50 million of equity has a 20% ROE. If that company borrows $50 million and buys back half its equity, reported earnings might stay roughly flat while ROE jumps toward 40%. The business did not improve; its capital structure changed.
ROIC, which divides after-tax operating profit by total invested capital (debt plus equity), removes this distortion. AAPL's ROIC of approximately 45.1% and MSFT's ROIC near 35% reflect genuine capital efficiency. A company with high ROE driven by debt financing looks similar to AAPL on a simple ROE screen but very different on an ROIC screen.
| Metric | What It Measures | Debt Sensitivity | Displayed in Simplywallst |
|---|---|---|---|
| ROE | Return on shareholders' equity | High | Yes, prominently |
| ROIC | Return on all invested capital | Minimal (strips debt) | Not displayed |
| P/E ratio | Price relative to reported earnings | Low | In value checks |
| P/B ratio | Price relative to book value | Moderate | In value checks |
| EV/EBITDA | Enterprise value relative to operating cash | None | Buried in financials tab |
Our glossary entry on ROE explains when ROE and ROIC converge and when they diverge, and which metric to prioritize for different types of capital structures.
Price-to-Book in Simplywallst: When It Works and When It Does Not
P/B is price per share divided by book value per share. Simplywallst uses P/B as one of the value checks, comparing it to the industry median.
P/B works best for businesses whose intrinsic value correlates with their balance sheet: banks, insurance companies, capital-intensive industrials, and holding companies like Berkshire Hathaway. BRK.B at a P/B near 1.5 passes simplywallst's P/B check accurately. Berkshire's book value approximates intrinsic value reasonably well given its portfolio of operating businesses and publicly traded securities.
P/B fails for asset-light businesses. A software company with $1 billion in market cap and $100 million in book value shows a P/B of 10x. Simplywallst scores this as a value failure. But if that software business generates $200 million in annual free cash flow and has no need for significant capital reinvestment, the P/B check is measuring the wrong thing. The book value does not reflect the value of the customer base, the code, or the operating model.
For more on when P/B is and is not the right valuation multiple, see the ValueMarkers glossary entry on P/B ratio.
What Simplywallst Cannot Tell You
Simplywallst cannot distinguish between a quality compounder at a fair price and a mediocre business at a cheap price. That distinction requires ROIC analysis, competitive moat assessment, and capital allocation track record review. None of those are captured in the snowflake.
The platform cannot assess earnings quality. The Piotroski F-Score and Beneish M-Score both address whether reported earnings reflect real cash generation and whether fundamentals are improving or deteriorating. Neither metric is available on simplywallst. You can run these checks through the ValueMarkers screener.
Simplywallst also cannot adjust for corporate actions that create one-time distortions. A business that completed a significant acquisition will show temporarily elevated debt and suppressed earnings comparisons, scoring poorly on health and past axes at precisely the moment a deal-driven mispricing might make it most interesting.
A Practical Workflow for Using Simplywallst
Run the simplywallst screen to generate a first-pass sort. Set minimum thresholds of 3/6 on value and 3/6 on health. This reduces a large universe to a manageable shortlist without reading any financial statements.
For each surviving candidate, work through to the financials tab and check EV/EBITDA against the stock's five-year historical median. More than 20% below that median without a business reason signals potentially real cheapness. At or above the median, the value axis pass may reflect sector-relative positioning rather than genuine undervaluation.
Check ROE alongside debt levels. If ROE exceeds 25% but net debt-to-equity is high, calculate whether the return comes from operations or from debt financing. If debt is a large driver, the quality signal is weaker than the ROE figure suggests.
Cross-reference each candidate with a Piotroski F-Score check in the ValueMarkers screener. A health score of 3/6 with an F-Score of 8 signals recovery. Build your own DCF for the final candidates using the ValueMarkers DCF calculator with your own visible assumptions.
Further reading: SEC Investor.gov · FINRA
Why simply wall street analysis Matters
This section anchors the discussion on simply wall street analysis. The detailed treatment, formula, and worked examples appear in the body of this article above. The points below summarize the most important takeaways for value investors who want to apply simply wall street analysis in real portfolio decisions. ValueMarkers exposes the underlying data on every covered ticker via the screener and stock profile pages, so the concepts in this article translate directly into actionable filters.
Key inputs for simply wall street analysis
See the main discussion of simply wall street analysis in the sections above for the full treatment, including the inputs, the calculation methodology, the typical sector benchmarks, and the most common pitfalls to avoid. The ValueMarkers screener lets value investors filter the full universe of 100,000+ stocks across 73 exchanges using simply wall street analysis alongside the rest of the 120-indicator composite, with sector percentiles and historical trends shown on every stock profile.
Sector benchmarks for simply wall street analysis
See the main discussion of simply wall street analysis in the sections above for the full treatment, including the inputs, the calculation methodology, the typical sector benchmarks, and the most common pitfalls to avoid. The ValueMarkers screener lets value investors filter the full universe of 100,000+ stocks across 73 exchanges using simply wall street analysis alongside the rest of the 120-indicator composite, with sector percentiles and historical trends shown on every stock profile.
Related ValueMarkers Resources
- Pe Ratio — Glossary entry for Pe Ratio
- Roe — Glossary entry for Roe
- Pb Ratio — Glossary entry for Pb Ratio
- Simply Wall Street — related ValueMarkers analysis
- Simply Wall St — related ValueMarkers analysis
- Motley Fool — related ValueMarkers analysis
Frequently Asked Questions
What is simplywallst?
Simplywallst is the colloquial name for Simply Wall Street, an Australian stock analysis platform founded in 2014 that provides visual fundamental analysis for over 100,000 securities across 50+ global exchanges. The platform produces a five-axis snowflake score for each covered security, aggregating binary check passes into axes labeled value, future, past, health, and dividends. It is used primarily by retail investors as a first-pass screening tool before deeper fundamental research.
How do you calculate simplywallst?
Simplywallst calculates its snowflake score by running binary pass/fail checks on each stock's fundamental data, then aggregating passes into axis scores on a 0-6 scale. For the value axis, checks include whether the P/E is below the sector median, whether the stock trades below a proprietary two-stage DCF estimate, and whether the P/B is below the industry norm. The five-axis snowflake chart plots all axis scores simultaneously. The maximum possible score is 30, with each axis capped at 6.
Why is simplywallst important for investors?
Simplywallst matters to investors primarily because it reduces the time required for a first-pass quality filter from hours to minutes. Manually checking P/E against sector medians, reviewing dividend payment history, and assessing debt loads for 50 stocks would take most investors a full day. Simplywallst aggregates that work into a visual format that takes roughly three minutes per stock. Its importance is proportional to how clearly the investor understands what the snowflake measures and what it does not.
How to use simplywallst in stock analysis?
Use simplywallst as the first of at least three analytical steps. In step one, apply minimum thresholds on the value and health axes to narrow a large list to a short list of candidates worth further investigation. In step two, open the detailed report for each candidate and manually check EV/EBITDA in the financials tab. In step three, build a DCF model with your own visible discount rate and growth assumptions rather than relying on the platform's proprietary estimate. Treat the simplywallst score as the starting hypothesis, not the final answer.
What is a good simplywallst for value stocks?
For value-focused investors, the most productive simplywallst profile combines a value axis score of 4-6/6 with a health axis score of 3/6 or above. For deep value work specifically, a value score of 5-6/6 with a P/E at least 20% below the sector median identifies stocks worth running through a full fundamental checklist. The health score matters as a companion check because a cheap stock with a weak balance sheet may be cheap for a valid structural reason rather than because of a temporary mispricing.
What are the limitations of simplywallst?
The main limitations of simplywallst for value investors are: the intrinsic value estimate uses a proprietary, non-adjustable DCF whose discount rate is not published; ROIC, Piotroski F-Score, and EV/EBITDA are absent from the default report; the binary check system loses gradient information (a P/E 1x below the sector median passes the same check as one 15x below it); and the future axis relies on analyst consensus, which carries a documented upward bias of approximately 18% per year on average at a 24-month forecast horizon. Investors who treat the snowflake as a final decision tool rather than a first filter accept unquantified analytical risk.
See how the simplywallst snowflake compares to the 120-indicator view in the ValueMarkers screener. The comparison surfaces data points the snowflake does not show and typically takes five minutes.
Written by Javier Sanz, Founder of ValueMarkers. Last updated April 2026.
Ready to find your next value investment?
ValueMarkers tracks 120+ fundamental indicators across 100,000+ stocks on 73 global exchanges. Run the methodology above in seconds with our stock screener, or see today's top-ranked names on the leaderboard.
Related tools: DCF Calculator · Methodology · Compare ValueMarkers
Disclaimer: This content is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a licensed financial advisor before making investment decisions.